She doesn't actively eyeball him at least; she's cautious but not skittish. It's also possibly questionable that she could kick his ass, though she'd definitely try: she's average height for a woman but extremely slenderly built. People have underestimated her before. She uses that as often as it's handed to her.

"Yeah, I do," she agrees, settling back in the chair. Wary still, not actively hostile, although in defense of her friends she'll get there on a dime if she's tested. "Who's Jesus to you?"